Poll
Board game expansions
🇩🇪 Original in German
Do you like playing with expansions, or do you often stick with the base game?
Add in the comments: which games only become really great with the expansion—where do you recommend getting them?
🇩🇪 Original in German
The Abyss Addon Leviathan is an addon I would never want to miss. It patches monster hunting, which is rather uninteresting in the base game
🇩🇪 Original in German
So for me, an expansion isn't always necessary. I liked Cascadia - I have the Landmarks expansion at home but have never played with it 🙈
🇩🇪 Original in German
It depends on what kind of expansion it is. When I buy a game, I assume that the author and the editorial team tested it until it works. That means the game is well playable as it is. No card should be too strong, no character board should be better than the others, and all sides of the game board should be balanced so that nothing needs to be readjusted. When I buy an expansion that extends the basic game principle, then I'm cautious. Because now a well-functioning game principle has been taken, broken open, and extended by some aspect. Personally, I'd say that in very few cases it makes things better. More often it backfires and a super polished game is no longer as pleasant to play as it was without the expansion. If it's a "more of the same" expansion, then I'm definitely in. That makes my game feel fresh again, I'm excited to explore the new cards, and the game principle I like stays untouched.
🇩🇪 Original in German
Hmm, tough question. We've basically only been playing Settlers with the Cities and Knights expansion since my childhood, so it's pretty much the base game for us 😂 sometimes the Seafarers expansion gets added too, but then it takes accordingly longer because we naturally adjust the victory points as well. Basically I'd say it depends on the game. If you like the base game, you don't necessarily need the expansion, but if you like the base game and want more variety, then the expansion is worth it.
🇩🇪 Original in German
Expansions that definitely make the base game better and don't noticeably make getting started harder: - Wingspan (Europe, Asia, Oceania) brings significantly more depth and decision-making options with very easy-to-understand additional rules - Terraforming Mars Prelude ensures a noticeably faster game start and speeds up the overall game without new rules.
🇩🇪 Original in German
I'm often an "expansion victim" - I buy them with or after when I like a game and then I mostly play it without them. Only with Heat do I use all expansions regularly, because they're new tracks and eight instead of six cars.
🇩🇪 Original in German
So far there's only one game where I'd say it has too many expansions, and that's Alhambra. Just wading through the selection of 30+ possible modules on your own is already exhausting. But otherwise I'm basically always on board with wanting to have every expansion for games, and I've done well with that so far.
🇩🇪 Original in German
Same for me as for Daniel. Except that we usually play with the expansion, but I do wonder whether it really had to be? Wingspan the expansion with the nectar I wouldn't have needed. The expansion for The Unconscious probably wouldn't have had to be either. The expansion for Eldritch Horror is mega, with tons of extra cards. Too many Bones unfortunately lives off the additional Gearlocs from the expansions, we have a lot of those too. These days I pay more attention to whether an expansion is really necessary.
🇩🇪 Original in German
I like collecting games and want them to be as complete as possible. Apart from that, there are also games that don't feel very finished without an expansion. With the first edition of Parks, for example, the Sternstunden expansion is a must-have, because otherwise the secret orders, which reward far too little, are totally crab.
🇩🇪 Original in German
Expansions... a tricky topic. Some I bought because the base game is top-notch and I simply wanted more. That started back then with DOMINION and CARCASSONNE. Other expansions I bought because they made the game playable with five (WASSERKRAFT, ROLLPLAYER,...). Then there are the ones that simply make the game better, like the combat system in AUFSTIEG DES IMPERIUMS for STAR WARS: REBELLION or also RISE OF IX for DUNE: IMPERIUM. Others have never been used to this day. Here I also had to learn that with a Kickstarter, sometimes the base game alone is enough.
🇩🇪 Original in German
Wow - looks like I hit a nerve 😅
🇩🇪 Original in German
I always find expansions exciting and buy them faster than is really good for me. I think that buying them late feels like an add-on and it fits in better if you have them from the start. In the end, though, it often makes learning the game harder. I'm particularly critical of modular expansions, since I hardly play the games often enough for every variant to really show itself. In that case, I'd rather have more of the same or just a few additional mechanisms. Most of my expansions, and the ones I actually use, are from Spirit Island. I don't have everything for it, but at least I find the random events make the game significantly better. Online I recently first got to know The White Castle, first with, then without the tea ceremony. With the base game, I felt something was missing.
🇩🇪 Original in German
Generally, I think it's great when a good game gets even better with an expansion. What annoys me is when, for example, Kickstarter already comes with 5 expansions, or a new expansion is simply released every 6 months.
🇩🇪 Original in German
Depends. We played Tainted Grail with all expansions and Dark Quarter too, but with that one you basically just get more story and that's great. With Fate Forge we also have all expansions, but with the one with the animals/companions I didn't feel like they "add" anything and I wouldn't have needed it. Since we like playing co-op, I was really happy about the expansion for Arnak and I thought the campaign was really great too. So expansions that turn a game into a co-op variant, always welcome. With Fantastische Reiche we decided against the expansion because the reviews were so bad and if I remember correctly it even makes the game rather worse. Conclusion: It depends on the expansion. More of the same, doesn't have to be. Variance or more stories, very welcome.
🇩🇪 Original in German
Most of the time I want the expansion if I like the base game. But most of the time it's not an existentially important improvement for me, but rather a nice to have, or I even like the base game better on its own. The few games where buying the expansion really paid off because I actually play them: Roll Player (because you don't just create heroes, but can also fight monsters with it), Race for the Galaxy (for the variety), Die Gilde der fahrenden Händler (for new maps), Monster Hunt for The Witcher - the old world (because the fight against the monsters becomes more interesting)
🇩🇪 Original in German
I think the problem is mostly that either it's been so long since you last played or you're playing with new people somehow, and then it always happens that it ends up being the base game. That happened to me especially with One Night Ultimate Werewolf. I have so much expansion stuff that I've never been able to try. haha At least with one of my favorite games, Root, it's the case that an expansion is simply a new faction that you use instead of other factions. So you don't always have to stick with the base game right away.
🇩🇪 Original in German
When I started collecting, I very often bought expansions right away too. Then I saw a YouTube video that kind of cured me of that - I don't remember who it was by - but the essence was roughly "if you haven't played a game at least 10 times, it makes zero sense to buy an expansion, no matter how good it is - because there's a big chance you won't play it more often even with the expansion." But there are definitely games where the expansion is important (Brügge...) But that's already heading back into this "how many of your games will you ever play how often" direction, which actually requires way too rational thinking for such an "unreasonable" hobby ^^
🇩🇪 Original in German
To give a few concrete examples here as well: I like campaign/story expansions like Verschwiegene Geschichten for Nemesis, or Aufstieg der Fenris for Scythe. They don't make the game better per se, but with a campaign the individual game session is embedded in a larger story and thereby somehow elevated. With Scythe I also like the modular game board, since it offers even more variety (as if there weren't enough 🙈). Another example would be Dune Imperium Uprising - not a real expansion, but definitely recommended over its predecessor (funny enough, I use the original as a card expansion for Uprising). A game that comes to mind that definitely gets better with the expansions is The Witcher Die Alte Welt, gains in complexity (which isn't very high anyway) and in variety.