Comments 9

↩ Replying to

Never shown publicly – only used to notify you about replies.

Spielwiese

🇩🇪 Original in German

For years, the Spirit Island box put me off. Boy, was I wrong, and what a gem was slumbering in there? 😍

RalfHH

🇩🇪 Original in German

I feel the same way. With smaller or abstract games it doesn't bother me as much. But with games that have a very extensive amount of material - especially with many and varied cards, I'm less inclined to play the game. That was the case for me with Arche Nova and Terraforming Mars, for example. Certainly great games, but the photos, which in my opinion aren't particularly special or beautiful shots and often don't even have a consistent style, ruin my desire to buy the game. Because for me part of the fun is also the visuals, I take pleasure in it when love has been put into the design and not just into the mechanics. I once bought the first edition of Brass cheaply because the reviews were good, but it sat unplayed in my cupboard for years. The somewhat loveless and old-fashioned prototype look kept me away. When the beautiful new edition of Brass came out as Brass Lancashire, I absolutely wanted to have it and I've played it too.

Screed

🇩🇪 Original in German

Super exciting topic. I had my eye on Arche Nova very early on, but didn't buy it because of the artwork. These days I'm leaning strongly toward buying it again. A lot of people say the artwork of Aufbruch nach Brighthelm is absolutely not for them. (I had shared a game moment about it) I find the game mechanics pretty cool, for example. But it's not surprising that the theme is so important—that's just what ends up on the table in front of the players.

Munky666

🇩🇪 Original in German

But the box just has power too! I've so often had a game in my hand / read reviews about it because the cover looked cool and then it was just garbage. I actually wouldn't have listed Arche Nova. Also exciting that you mention it here 😅

Destragon

🇩🇪 Original in German

Definitely AI-generated stuff. Otherwise I'm not so sure. Not a fan of giant heads like in Santorini. It also depends heavily on editing and formatting. Maybe you have nice artwork, but the different areas on the map aren't nicely separated from each other, or you have maps like in Hegemony that are mostly black text on a white background.

Dan

🇩🇪 Original in German

Yeah, as mentioned in another post about cover design, for example "wonderful Creatures" was already brought up — the cover doesn't appeal to me at all/even puts me off. But the material looks wonderful again! With other games though, the complete artwork just isn't my thing. So Spirit Island is also on my list and I haven't played it yet either but apparently it's really good.

Ücki

🇩🇪 Original in German

With Carpe Diem, it's not the cover but the graphic style of the tiles that puts people off—sometimes it's just a green mush you can make out. That makes the game really hard to play. But it still gets to the table because it's really good.

Post ID: #1796 — Please include this ID for questions or deletion requests.