Poll
You are stranded on an island and can only take one board game from your collection - which one is i

You are stranded on an island and can only take one board game from your collection - which one is it?

🇩🇪 Original in German

You're stranded on an island (alone or with your game group) and can only take one board game from your collection - which one is it? Which game can you play over and over again and why?

Poll

14 votes
Multiple choice: up to 2 answers ends on 24.11. 12:49
  1. nur EIN Spiel - dann besser gleich abnippeln!
  2. oh da fallen mir direkt 10 Spiele ein.... VERDAMMT!

No names are shown – only the number of votes. You can change your choice while the poll is open.

Dan Follow
317 Views

Comments 19

↩ Replying to

Never shown publicly – only used to notify you about replies.

Daniel Editorial

🇩🇪 Original in German

Hehe... good question! I honestly wouldn't be able to decide... If one with as much game material as possible, so that you can then invent many more games yourself and pass the time that way.

Screed

🇩🇪 Original in German

Hmm, probably either Vantage, because there's just so massively much to discover in that game. Or Eldritch Horror, because we can keep playing it over and over and the win rate is very low, so it'll be a while before you even win at all. 😅 And both games take relatively long, so the throughput of games per day isn't that high. Generally though, one game for the rest of your life is pretty much torture 🫣

Thomas

🇩🇪 Original in German

Hmmm 🤔🤔🤔 Then I'll take Mensch Ärgere dich nicht! Haha - no, honestly, no clue! I'd go along with @Daniel and bring a game collection or something so you can make up your own games at the beach/in the jungle and use the materials from it.

Ixid

🇩🇪 Original in German

Even though it would be torture to only be allowed to take one thing, the answer comes pretty easily to me: GLOOMHAVEN. Especially because I still haven't finished it 🙈, but also because I can imagine playing through it with different character classes. Plus, it offers quite a lot of content and definitely scenarios that can't be discovered in a single playthrough... And then I'll also meet Friday or Wilson and can explain the game to them 😂

Spielwiese

🇩🇪 Original in German

It definitely won't be boring with Jumanji 😂

RalfHH

🇩🇪 Original in German

Ten good reasons to bring CASCADIA along: 1. the box is so small that I can still haul along other life-essential stuff 2. the game is so simple that I feel like playing it every day too. 3. it's so accessible that even fellow survivors on the island can join in 4. there's a solo variant in case I have to eat all my fellow survivors 5. it doesn't take that long, so I still have enough time to take care of fishing and hunting 6. the different scoring keeps it from getting too repetitive 7. with the challenges you almost get a kind of campaign that I can play for a really long time 8. if it ever does get boring, I've got the Landmarks expansion right there in the box 9. the wind doesn't blow any cards away 10. once I'm tired of my island's palms and fish, I can dream of North American forests with bears, deer, and Douglas fir cones

Firehead

🇩🇪 Original in German

Scythe or Arche Nova, I could always play those.

Nils Editorial

🇩🇪 Original in German

Obviously, Spirit Island with all expansions 😀

Alex BSN Editorial

🇩🇪 Original in German

That would actually be a good choice. Lots of variety, a huge range of different difficulty levels, island theme. I'd be in on that ...

Evil_Ernie666

🇩🇪 Original in German

Definitely HeroQuest!

Daniel Editorial

🇩🇪 Original in German

why did I know you were going to write that 😂

DestoSkel

🇩🇪 Original in German

Obviously: Robinson Crusoe! 🏝️😂 Then I can play a board game on a deserted island in which I fight for survival on a deserted island. And if I lose, I don't even have to set it up again – I can just reenact the defeat live. 🤣🎲

Michael Editorial

🇩🇪 Original in German

I'd bring a role-playing game like THE DARK EYE, D&D or SHADOWRUN. We could come up with new adventures ourselves and we'd always experience something new.

Mark Red

🇩🇪 Original in German

Then Gloomhaven. Has been sitting unplayed in the cupboard for, uh... 4/5 years. So plenty to discover. I've also got the solo scenario book with me.

TomHai

🇩🇪 Original in German

Of course Robinson Crusoe 😁 And quickly get the adventure book to go with it. That gives you plenty to play for a long time and the atmosphere fits perfectly too 😁

bLoodY

🇩🇪 Original in German

Probably Terraforming Mars. Timeless classic.

Post ID: #1966 — Please include this ID for questions or deletion requests.