In the end it's probably the mix that does it, and not every game covers just one genre, but which mechanic do you actually enjoy playing the most?
I don't have enough options, the voting continues in a separate post!
Poll
19 votes
Multiple choice: up to 10 answers
This poll has ended. Thanks for taking part!
Final result
Worker Placement73,7 %14
Dice Placement42,1 %8
Drafting26,3 %5
Engine Building78,9 %15
Deck Building68,4 %13
Area Control42,1 %8
Roll/Flip & Write26,3 %5
Set Collection21,1 %4
Trick Taking21,1 %4
Tile Placement42,1 %8
No names are shown – only the number of votes. You can change your choice while the poll is open.
Unfortunately I can't start another poll, so it won't be all that representative because at least the following mechanisms are still missing:
K - Bag building
L - Push your Luck
M - Pick Up and Delivery
N - Memory games
O - Deduction
P - Legacy
Q - Real-time
R - Action Points
S - Coop
T - Solitaire
And definitely many more..
Totally fine as it is, because they might double up at some point anyway. I just wasn't expecting it to stop at j. To be fair: I think very few surveys need that many answer options. :D
I don't really have a favorite mechanism at all; sure, there are some I like more or less. But there's neither the one where I wouldn't join in nor the other with which every game becomes good.
I tried to figure it out via BGG Collection Export and with the help of Gemini and Google Sheets, and then ended up at https://geekgroup.app/. You can really find a ton of stats based on your BGG collection and played games - I'll put the result in another comment right away
@Daniel, if you still need ideas for the collections here on playednow - there's a lot of inspiration there o.O
After a bit of back and forth, the picture answers the question about the collection.
Things I like also show up pretty high up there, but my collection is also tailored to my family. Some mechanics are really exciting but only show up in games that I'd probably never or only very rarely get to the table. So I don't own those.
But I really like:
- Hand management
- Cooperative play
- Variable player powers
- Drafting
- Simultaneous action selection
- Engine/deck/bag building
- Action points
Ultimately though, it always depends on the specific game — I also quite enjoy trick-taking games sometimes, for example.
I don't like so much:
- Pens in the game (especially those dry-erase ones, no matter how good they are)
- Player elimination (when it happens too early)
A favorite mechanic wasn't among them either, but I found the journey quite exciting :D
I love worker placement, dice placement, roll and write, and tile placement. Preferably something a bit more relaxed too.
I also really enjoy trick-taking games and deduction.
The only thing I really don't like is real-time. That stresses me out too much.
I think with real-time I'd be one of the reasons for the stress. 🙈
Sometimes when my wife takes too long, I can't resist making a comment. But she also tends to fall into the notorious analysis paralysis.
That's a tough question. Right now I'd say my most-played stuff (besides party games) is engine building, deckbuilding, and area control. But of course it's also great when games don't fit into those schemas at all.
So like you actually already wrote above, it comes down to the mix — if you only had bag images in the cupboard, for example, I think that wouldn't make you happy in the long run. I like co-op games best, deduction and dice games like Dice Throne, and of course the good party games.
But these days almost all gamer games or above combine multiple mechanics. In my opinion that's already an unofficial standard. Only the smaller games limit themselves to one mechanic.
True. That sometimes seems pretty clumsy 😅
Transmissions is one example. You run around with robots over played cards, collect software for passive or active abilities and items for set bonuses. The bigger the set, the more points. And then for some reason there are also pipe tiles you can collect and have to puzzle together. Huh, why? 😂
Definitely co-op, and otherwise it also depends a lot on the game. I love Strike, the dice push-your-luck game. But when I have to redo everything in campaign games because of a stupid dice roll, the fun is limited. What I definitely don't like at all are bluffing games, playing hard against each other and messing things up for the other person.
Deck-building and engine-building always work for me, and I also enjoy area control.
But various others too.
Trick-taking, deduction, and memory games usually don't appeal to me.
According to my own evaluation, my favorite mechanism is "Hand Management," meaning anything where you have cards in your hand and can usually do different things with them (multi-use cards).
Post ID: #1872 — Please include this ID for questions or deletion requests.
Notification settings
Want to know what’s happening in the community? Choose yourself what you get notified about - new posts, comments or hearts on your posts.
Go to your profile → Settings to adjust your notifications.
Cookie Settings
We use cookies and locally stored settings. Essential cookies keep the site functional; Google Analytics is only used with your consent (anonymised). Cloudflare Web Analytics also counts page views without cookies. Details and revocation: Privacy Policy
Essential
Session, language and display notices — without these the site cannot work.
Always active
Statistics
Anonymised visitor statistics (Google Analytics, with IP anonymisation, without ad personalisation).
🇩🇪 Original in German
Unfortunately I can't start another poll, so it won't be all that representative because at least the following mechanisms are still missing: K - Bag building L - Push your Luck M - Pick Up and Delivery N - Memory games O - Deduction P - Legacy Q - Real-time R - Action Points S - Coop T - Solitaire And definitely many more..
🇩🇪 Original in German
I'm changing it so that polls can be edited. I had limited polls to one per week for established users so there wouldn't be a flood of polls.
🇩🇪 Original in German
Then I'll add los to my adef too 😅
🇩🇪 Original in German
@Spielwiese you can edit the polls now. Have a nice weekend 😉
🇩🇪 Original in German
I don't really have a favorite mechanism at all; sure, there are some I like more or less. But there's neither the one where I wouldn't join in nor the other with which every game becomes good.
🇩🇪 Original in German
Which ones are among the more popular ones for you? Or which would I often find on your shelf?
🇩🇪 Original in German
I've been wondering that myself since your survey, I'll analyze that at some point
🇩🇪 Original in German
I tried to figure it out via BGG Collection Export and with the help of Gemini and Google Sheets, and then ended up at https://geekgroup.app/. You can really find a ton of stats based on your BGG collection and played games - I'll put the result in another comment right away @Daniel, if you still need ideas for the collections here on playednow - there's a lot of inspiration there o.O
🇩🇪 Original in German
After a bit of back and forth, the picture answers the question about the collection. Things I like also show up pretty high up there, but my collection is also tailored to my family. Some mechanics are really exciting but only show up in games that I'd probably never or only very rarely get to the table. So I don't own those. But I really like: - Hand management - Cooperative play - Variable player powers - Drafting - Simultaneous action selection - Engine/deck/bag building - Action points Ultimately though, it always depends on the specific game — I also quite enjoy trick-taking games sometimes, for example. I don't like so much: - Pens in the game (especially those dry-erase ones, no matter how good they are) - Player elimination (when it happens too early) A favorite mechanic wasn't among them either, but I found the journey quite exciting :D
🇩🇪 Original in German
I love worker placement, dice placement, roll and write, and tile placement. Preferably something a bit more relaxed too. I also really enjoy trick-taking games and deduction. The only thing I really don't like is real-time. That stresses me out too much.
🇩🇪 Original in German
I really can't name just one favorite mechanism. There are soooo many great games with different mechanisms.
🇩🇪 Original in German
That's a tough question. Right now I'd say my most-played stuff (besides party games) is engine building, deckbuilding, and area control. But of course it's also great when games don't fit into those schemas at all.
🇩🇪 Original in German
So like you actually already wrote above, it comes down to the mix — if you only had bag images in the cupboard, for example, I think that wouldn't make you happy in the long run. I like co-op games best, deduction and dice games like Dice Throne, and of course the good party games.
🇩🇪 Original in German
As you already wrote, for me it's often the mix of mechanics. I always find it cool when something tried and true is newly interlocked and combined.
🇩🇪 Original in German
Definitely co-op, and otherwise it also depends a lot on the game. I love Strike, the dice push-your-luck game. But when I have to redo everything in campaign games because of a stupid dice roll, the fun is limited. What I definitely don't like at all are bluffing games, playing hard against each other and messing things up for the other person.
🇩🇪 Original in German
[Comment deleted]
🇩🇪 Original in German
Deck-building and engine-building always work for me, and I also enjoy area control. But various others too. Trick-taking, deduction, and memory games usually don't appeal to me.
🇩🇪 Original in German
According to my own evaluation, my favorite mechanism is "Hand Management," meaning anything where you have cards in your hand and can usually do different things with them (multi-use cards).