Game moment
Austausch-/Deluxe Material für eure Spiele – What is your stance on this?

Austausch-/Deluxe Material für eure Spiele

What is your stance on this?

🇩🇪 Original in German

Since the question about expansions already came up, how do you feel about deluxe material for your games? Is standard material enough for you, or do you prefer it higher quality? And while we're on the subject: cards, sleeved or preferably unsleeved? My answers: if I really like a game, I'd prefer the material to be as good as possible. Cards are almost always sleeved. (Example image: Spirit Island wooden and cardboard tokens)
Mabruk Follow
Current trends
336 Views

Comments 19

↩ Replying to

Never shown publicly – only used to notify you about replies.

Dan

🇩🇪 Original in German

so I do like nicer materials but it doesn't have to be. Depending on the game and how often it hits the table it's of course nice too. and maybe that means it comes off the shelf onto the table even more often! ;)

Sina

🇩🇪 Original in German

Also definitely sleeve cards if possible, that way they last longer, especially when you play the game often or take it to friends and it's a fun evening and a drink gets spilled, then the cards aren't immediately ruined.. My opinion on deluxe material has changed over the last few years.. earlier I would have said oh the standard material is enough, but earlier with many games the standard material was also higher quality.. Example Siedler earlier wood now weird plastic.. And I'm just a fan of wooden figures With tokens that you just place in front of you it doesn't matter, they can be cardboard, but something I actively move or keep pulling out of a bag etc. In that case I'd rather have the high-quality material

Joellenbecker

🇩🇪 Original in German

Sleeves: always! Deluxe tokens: only if they're really much nicer. With Arnak and SETI, for example, they're not necessary, I think. What I'm most likely to swap out is coins. The money in Arche Nova, for example, is just terrible. So I use my metal coins instead. I have a set from Scythe that has a good denomination range (1, 3, 5, 10, 20). It doesn't always quite fit thematically, but I use it for Great Western Trail, for example, too. Only for Carl von Linne did I treat myself to the original matching metal coins. They're really great, and the denominations there are just 1 and 2.

Screed

🇩🇪 Original in German

Oh man, I'm a fan of deluxe material. Most of the time it's too expensive for me though. The deluxe material from EOS and Vantage is mega, for example. The deluxe resources from Brass Birmingham are also super nice. Sleeving rather rarely. Yeah cards do wear out, but with the sheer number of different games it also takes a while until you've played a game often enough for it to wear down.

LarsVader87

🇩🇪 Original in German

I think deluxe materials are pretty cool and I keep checking for ones for my favorite games, but so far they've always been too expensive for me. For example, for Dune Imperium Uprising they're more expensive than the base game 😵 So I designed my own stickers for the resources and painstakingly cut them out and stuck them on. But I'm very happy with them 😁

Spielwiese

🇩🇪 Original in German

Rather get more games, organizers, or expansions for the money than pick up wooden or metal tokens. Deluxe tokens make for a nicer game feel, no question! However, just because of sustainability alone (where do the old tokens go?) and for cost reasons, I skip deluxe components.

Spielwiese

🇩🇪 Original in German

A new trend I'm currently noticing with deluxe components is the emergence of acrylic tokens.

Ücki

🇩🇪 Original in German

I'm more of a purist myself, I don't sleeve my cards and I've never swapped out any material either. But if there's nice material included, I'm of course happy about it.

Munky666

🇩🇪 Original in German

I always prefer using Deluxe material, even though in hindsight the standard would usually have been enough... With unsleeved cards I just like the feel better... And you should also be able to see that the cards are being used...

Ixid

🇩🇪 Original in German

If it doesn't get outrageously expensive, I'm also happy to go for Deluxe versions. Otherwise, I also 3D print quite a bit, especially terrain.

Ergo

🇩🇪 Original in German

We sleeve cards if they're sensitive, have nice artwork, or get shuffled a lot. For tokens etc., I think deluxe material is pretty nice, especially when the cardboard version is so thin. I don't need miniatures since I don't have time to paint them and I really don't find them that great unpainted. I think a double-sided printed cardboard marker where you can immediately see which figure it is is much better. I thought the printed thick cardboard discs instead of minis in Fate Forge were really great.

RalfHH

🇩🇪 Original in German

Even though the deluxe materials are often really nicely produced: I'd rather spend the money on an expansion or another game. I only use sleeves when I really like the card layout AND when it's a deckbuilder, the cards are drafted, or they get handled a lot for other reasons. For the new edition of Seven Wonders with the metallic backs or with Arnak, for example, I sleeved them. My fellow players just have to deal with it when it's a bit prickly.

Denny Crane

🇩🇪 Original in German

I used to pimp out everything back in the day. These days I try to keep sustainability in mind a bit more. Then it doesn't have to be the umpteenth playmat, or cards only get sleeved if they're shuffled x times in the game. That's why I find it easier to go for Deluxe Editions that are actually offered without the standard equipment. That way I can have my luxury upgrade without the basic accessories unnecessarily lying around at my place and having been unnecessarily produced.

Destragon

🇩🇪 Original in German

It really depends on the implementation. Sometimes deluxe stuff is just genuinely cooler with no downsides, but sometimes not so much. For example, for Deckers you can find deluxe miniatures and acrylic tokens. That sounds pretty good in itself, but I somehow prefer the cardboard standees with the artwork over miniatures that all look very similar and are unpainted unless you're an artist yourself. And with the tokens in that game, they actually have two different sides with a limited number. I think with the acrylic version the different sides are different tokens? That makes it a bit more cumbersome. Or with Container there's a deluxe version where all the containers and ships are made of metal instead of plastic. They feel great in your hand, but if you want to take the game to meetups, then you really feel the huge difference in weight. haha Cards I actually prefer unsleeved, they look nicer and feel better, but with Root I'm currently thinking I should probably do it now, because I play it often enough to justify it.

Post ID: #1809 — Please include this ID for questions or deletion requests.